The Leader in You by Dale Carnegie & Associates, Inc
Levin, S., & Crom, M. (1999). The Leader in You. New York: Simon & Schuster.
At age twenty-three I was one of the unhappiest young men in New York. I was selling motor trucks for a living. My decision was this: I would give up the work I loathed, and since I had spent four years studying in the State Teachers College at Warrensburg, Missouri, preparing to teach, I would make my living teaching adult classes.... I wanted to live to write and write to live. -Dale Carnegie
Dale Carnegie never wrote the great American novel, but his remarkable success as a teacher, a business man, and a writer of human-relations books has made him an inspiration to people around the world-a true leader. He achieved all that by following the rules he set out for himself. Even though some principles he came up with for some people are common sense, for others when it is on paper or on the screen, the light in their heads glows even more.
These principles are uniquely suited to the current high-stress, fast-moving, uncertain world we live in.
-Look at things from the other person’s perspective
-Offer genuine appreciation and praise
-Harness the mighty power of enthusiasm
-Respect the dignity of others
-Don’t be overly critical
-Give people a good reputation to live up to
-Keep a sense of fun and balance in your life
The Leader in You has benefited three generations of students and business people from this essential wisdom. Because the business world is changing with competition and technological races, no longer can businesses safely ignore their customers’ wants and needs. This change will require a whole new breed of leaders, a leader quite unlike the bosses most of us have worked for and some of us have perhaps become. According to the book, the leaders of tomorrow will have to establish a real vision and a sense of values for the organizations they wish to lead. These leaders will have to communicate and motivate far more effectively than did leaders of the past.
The first step toward success is identifying your own leadership strengths.
In the postwar years American companies seemed to prosper almost regardless of what they did. Big American-based companies, backed by big labor and big government, set the standards for everyone else. In the meantime, Japan was thinking ahead. They built a company dedicated to employee involvement, quality improvement, and customer satisfaction-and worked to unite all the employees behind these goals. Japan became a leader in technological innovation, but technology alone is never enough in difficult times. The means of communication are available but it doesn’t mean that people have learned to communicate well. So, what is the good of all this information if people don’t know how to communicate it well?
The book gives an example of how the Graduate School of Business at Harvard is seeing a satisfaction of technical competence, but when it comes to teaching human-relations skills, Harvard is stepping up its efforts because this seems to be the area where improvements are needed. Oral and written communication, teamwork, and other human skills are the skills that will go the farthest in determining the success of leaders. Similar to the “human skill” section of the skills approach, these skills have the ability to change people from managing others to leading others. The leaders can “change lives from resentment to contentment, from apathy to involvement, from failure to success.” As noted in the book, a few people can do this instinctively; most people have to be educated. Unlike the trait approach that says that certain people were born with special traits that made them great leaders, it relates more to the skills approach.
To take a cynical approach, I would point out that one weakness would be that most of the principles that Carnegie points out are obvious. I think he knew that they were obvious principles, but what made the principles strong were all the compelling examples he used to describe them. He includes anecdotes from Bill Clinton to Adolph Seltz, a salesman; Chrysler organization to IBM; from business situations to financial settings; anyone, anywhere can relate to at least one of the examples he uses. A major advantage to these principles is that he explains how skills lead to effective leadership performance by incorporating different theories to back up what he says, unlike the skills approach that does not explain how. Just like the style approach, Carnegie talks about task behaviors and relationship behaviors. He doesn’t mention which behavior is better than the other but says that effective leaders come in all forms of behavior. Carnegie continues to write that a leader must have a goal or a vision because it “articulates a view of realistic, credible, attractive future...”
Communication is built on trusting relationships.
The three basic concepts to follow for successful communication:
1. Make communication a priority
2. Be open to other people
3. Create a receptive environment for communication
He says that talented leaders come in all personality types and he mentions that all the brilliant ideas in the world are worthless if you don’t share them, similar to the situational leadership approach. He uses the example of American Airlines, and how management goes around and talks to subordinates. “Barking rights” were thought to be the way to be the boss. As Eisenhower once said, “I would rather persuade a man to go along because once he has been persuaded, he will stick. If I scare him, he will stay just as long as he is scared, and then he is gone.”
Team Players are leaders of tomorrow. Motivation can never be forced. People have to want to do a good job.
It’s a leaders’ job to foster these feelings: “We are in this together.” “We are part of a team.” “What we do is valuable.”
Show people, that you trust, respect, and care about them. Do that, and you will be surrounded by motivated people. As Bill Geppert says, “take care of your people, and the business takes care of itself.” Successful leaders create teams.
Carnegie emphasizes how important teams are in organizations, and if one wants to be an effective leader, he or she has to master a few basic coaching techniques.
-Create a shared sense of purpose
-Make the goals team goals
-Treat people like the individuals they are
-Make each member responsible for the team product
-Share the glory, accept the blame
-Take every opportunity to build confidence on the team
-Be involved, stay involved.
Modern organization cannot be found with boss and subordinates. Instead, companies are putting people together from different departments, i.e. engineers and salespeople to come up with a product. This is an effective way because many perspectives come out to make an effective product or service. The world is too complicated for one individual to invent by himself. You need several people from different disciplines working together at the same time. This approach is similar to the team leadership approach mentioned in Leadership. Just like in any approach, there are some disadvantages of this approach. One being that if you are placed in a team, the goals might be too challenging to accomplish. The leader might put more pressure on you because you are in a team.
The next example given by Carnegie relates to the situational approach of leadership. Dr. Coyne, a radiologist, was one of the first doctors on the scene of an Avianca Boeing 727 that crashed in Long Island. No one spoke any English. Coyne’s focus was so intense that everything peripheral was just blocked out of his mind. He discovered how focused he had been later when he spoke about the accident. He had not heard the ambulances or the helicopters; everything was quite because he was focused. Intense one hundred percent focus. That’s what got Coyne through. As explained in the situational approach, leaders like Dr. Coyne, need to be flexible and adapt their style to the requirements of the situation.
The criticism with situational leadership is that there is a limited amount of studies done on situational leadership, which makes it ambiguous regarding how the approach conceptualizes certain aspects of the leadership process.
Nobody is more persuasive than a good listener.
There are two very good reasons to listen to other people. You learn things that way, and people respond to those who listen to them. One evidence that he used was when Carnegie was at a dinner party and met a botanist, whom he had never had a conversation with and knew nothing about plants or gardens. At the dinner party he had mentioned in front of everyone that Carnegie was ‘an interesting conversationalist.’ He wrote: “I had said hardly anything at all! I know botany as much as I know about the anatomy of a penguin. But I had done this: I had listened intently. I had because I was genuinely interested. And so I had him thinking of me as a good conversationalist when in reality i had been merely a good listener and had encouraged him to talk.
A goal is a dream with a deadline.
Those who fail to establish independent goals for themselves become the “me-toos” of the world. The “me-toos” follow and never lead. Have a goal clearly in mind, something you really want; believe in yourself and be persistent; and don’t allow yourself to be distracted. That is similar to the path-goal theory in Leadership, derived from expectancy theory, which suggests that subordinates will be motivated if they think they are capable of performing their work.
Leaders never lose their focus. They keep their eyes on the big picture. A lot of the success is just “stick-to-itiveness.” A willingness to find out why someone said no-and maybe convince the person to say yes.
Take your worries and energize your life.
“Those who do not know how to fight worry, die young.” This section is probably one of the most important sections in the book because I have never seen any author that writes about leadership also write about worrying. Yet, this crippling disease of worry is one of the biggest problems facing humanity, and it diminishes your ability to lead. Nowhere is this more true than in today’s volatile business world i.e. layoffs, downsizing, cutbacks and buyouts are a few examples.
Instead, try to follow these simple rules:
-Take comfort from the law of averages
-Cooperate with the inevitable
-Keep things in perspective
-Get busy
The applicability of the perspectives in all of the situations are very adaptable. One can use these principles on a daily basis even with family and friends. What’s needed now is leadership, to help people achieve what they are capable of, to establish a vision for the future, to encourage, to coach and to mentor, and to establish and maintain successful relationships-all of which Carnegie points out. Research done at the Carnegie Foundation showed that about 15 percent of one’s financial success is due to one’s technical knowledge, and about 85 percent is due to skill in human engineering-to personality and the ability to lead people. Carnegie also follows the concepts of transformational leadership in that he is concerned in values, ethics, standards, and long-term goals, and includes assessing followers’ motives satisfying their needs, and treating them as full human beings.